Sunday, December 20, 2009

The Rolling Stones-EXILE ON MAIN ST. ORIGINAL UK VINYL Recorded by PBTHAL




This is an incredible rip of EXILE by PBTHAL, which I believe is not even available on his blog. Anyway, I think everyone should know about the incredible work he's doing.

This was recorded differently than the THEIR SATANIC MAJESTIES REQUEST rip I posted earlier was recorded, different person! PBTHAL captures at 192khz, way higher than the SATANIC REQUEST guy did. PBTHAL also has arguably better hardware. It is then dithered down to Redbook standard 16bit / 44.1khz. In other words, analog captured as highly as consumer hardware really even allows. Now. Which is insanely better than what was available to studios in 1987, or whenever, when CDs of old albums were being made from master tapes with early, primitive DACs. Even remasters that claim to use original masters now tend to do who knows what to them.

Here's some literal symbolism for you: look at the sleeve art from the vinyl, and now compare it to the sleeve from the CD version. Notice the difference? The art on the vinyl is a messy patchwork with obvious masking tape holding the pieces together. The CD version smooths everything down until it all looks like one professional layer. Sloppy replaced with the illusion of sloppy.

Now listen to the original mix. There are tons of mistakes. You hear dropouts, wrong plug-ins, rumbles, sibilance. These aren't from the medium of vinyl, trust me. Jimmy Miller knew what he was doing. This was an intentionally sprawling mess in concept.



You feel like you're in the room during Sweet Virginia, I turned my head when the saxophone came in. Hear the deep thud in the right ear during the beginning of Loving Cup. Hey, what was that weird squelch of the vocals as it went into the verse? It was Jimmy Miller or Keith Richards de-pressing a button when layering takes into the mix.

You might find yourself saying, "Ian, come on. There's distortion during Torn and Frayed!" To which I would say, "Listen closer, idiot! That's TAPE FLUTTER. From the MASTER TAPE. It's SUPPOSED TO BE THERE!" This album feels lived in. It creaks like old floorboards.

Guess stuff like that gets washed away in numbing barrage of Noise Reduction during the CD remaster.

This has been THE DEFINITIVE EXILE for me for about a year. Which makes it pretty much my favorite recording of anything, ever. There's like maybe three albums ever made that top this for me. It's as good as it's ever going to get. I've taken the liberty of making this rip available in MP3, again, for those people that just want to hear the mix but are unconcerned with lossless fidelity and just want it on their iPods.

Yes, I know. This was pretty much a big slab of hyperbole. But there aren't reviews specific to the original vinyl, comparing it to subsequent remasters. So I had to write something. Cut me some slack, jerk!

Please consider other excellent recordings of rare vinyl from PBTHAL:
http://pbthal.blogspot.com

DOWNLOAD:
The Rolling Stones-EXILE ON MAIN ST. ORIGINAL UK VINYL by PBTHAL (1972)
zs mu
FLAC

MP3 VERSION
rs mu
320kbps

19 comments:

  1. Loving these super high fidelity Stones records! Thanks, as always.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Ian,

    When I download the vinyl rips there's no data in the RARs. I have the same problem w/ pbthal. Is there some file extraction thing I need? Also, excellent blog! Good luck to you...

    Rob

    ReplyDelete
  3. Rob, the RAR is 400 megs, how can there be no data? Can you play FLAC files?

    ReplyDelete
  4. oh rad! haven't heard a vinyl rip of this - ever ! - gasp --- but i've been thinking about this album lately... or it's been vying? anyway, awesome sir ian:)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you and Merry Christmas

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for this, Ian. Just A/B'ing 'Rocks Off' it's shocking what they did to the remaster. I mean, the opening riff in the left channel is HUGE and comically pristine sounding compared to the vinyl. And amazingly, on the vinyl rip the sound actually gets louder towards the end of the song. On the remaster, the RMS is the same at :30 as it is :30 from the end.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Oh, M. Campbell, thank you for the outside confirmation! I was worried people were going to think I was just imagining the differences!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Ian -
    I'm looking forward to comparing this rip to Mickboy's, which I have been listening to religiously for the better part of a year. Mickboy is some Dutch sound geek who finds the best vinyl versions he can and "remixes" the sound on his own mixing desk or something. IMHO, he did a bang up job with the Stones catalog. I've also been impressed by Purple Chick's Beatles stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thanks for the great rip! This just blasted off my computer speakers as I downloaded. Can't wait to hear this on my home system. Groovy!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Excellent rip! This came blasting through my computer speakers as I downloaded. Can't wait to hear this on my home system. Groovy!

    ReplyDelete
  11. There's a definate difference, I just stumbled onto this, and you sir have blown my mind!

    The pedal steel of Al Perkins is notably clearer, louder and crisper than on the CD reissues I've heard.
    Most rock producers have no idea of how to deal with steel guitar, Miller knows guitars, and it really shows on this record.

    Nice work Ian, thanks for sharing

    J.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This was pretty much a big slab of hyperbole.

    I call it "truth".

    Somehow the greatest rock and roll LP just got better!

    Thanks for sharing the pbthal.

    ReplyDelete
  13. My first time here.
    Thankyou very much for this classic Ian.
    A friend of our's died in 2001 (just 50 yrs)his all time fav was 'Exiles'
    His copy was the original copy he bought back in the 70's, it had partied hard!
    I was given the honour of ripping and distributing it amongst us who were left...snap crackle pop and omitted tracks because the turntable couldn't fully cope.
    We still have a beer with Barry and Exiles on the occasions...I think he would be excited listening to this rip.
    Thanks again
    and I'll be back

    ReplyDelete
  14. BTW excited would be an understatement...if he could hear it, he would wake the dead!
    Brian

    ReplyDelete
  15. thanx for sharing
    thanx for mentioning PBthal
    thanx for being an evolved human being

    cheers.

    ReplyDelete
  16. You wrote: PBTHAL captures at 192khz, way higher than the SATANIC REQUEST guy did

    The Satanic request guy here...
    I record at 96 and not 192 kHz because there simply is no notable audio information above 45 kHz on any vinyl record. I share my rips in that same resolution and also in CD quality, unlike PB who only shares his recordings in CD quality. So whatever information he captured above 20k is not preserved within his final uploads. Not that this really matters, our hearing only goes to about 19kHz (when lucky). But insinuating that my rip would be off lesser quality because of this is just wrong.

    PS

    ReplyDelete
  17. The argument "it doesn't matter how well your capture is after a point when it is dithered down to Redbook" doesn't really wash with me. The better the capture, the better the final product no matter what you convert it to.

    I take your point though, and enjoy your work PS

    ReplyDelete
  18. Thanks to your post on Pbthal's rip of this excellent album, I just discovered this early rip of his, and your blog. I'm really looking forward to this. Thank you very, very much!

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thank You for pointing me to this UK press of Exile.And thanks for the intro to your site it looks fab.I am heartened by the number of blogs about vinyl, Keep on keepin on.

    Dr Debaser

    ReplyDelete