Saturday, March 13, 2010

Nirvana-THE CHOSEN REJECTS (2009 compilation by JWB)




Here's an essential Nirvana set. It's a bootleg, but it absolutely destroys that piece of garbage WITH THE LIGHTS OUT any day of the week. This also has BETTER SOURCED material. The "official" box used multiple-generation dubs no better than those OUTCESTICIDE bootlegs from the 1990s, and then tried to cover up the poor sound by compressing the shit out of everything.

I don't know who JWB is exactly, but he seems to have gotten his hands on lots of pre-broadcast masters, direct tapes, and the lowest generation dubs I've ever heard. I suspect he's not far from the inner circle, quietly funneling things out he suspects will never see the proper light of day otherwise. The quality is that good.


Tracklist, click for bigger.

I went ahead and added JWB's separate compilation of Nirvana's BBC appearances. Now this includes mostly Peel Sessions, so between THE CHOSEN REJECTS and INCESTICIDE you're only left with 2-3 unheard tracks on the BBC comp. But those tracks are why I bothered throwing in an almost redundant set.

DOWNLOAD:
DISC I: HOME DEMOS
mu rs

DISC II: STUDIO SESSIONS
mu rs

DISC III: BROADCASTS
mu rs

DISC IV: LIVE RARITIES
mu rs

COMPLETE BBC SESSIONS
mu rs
320kbps

19 comments:

  1. I don't normally swear that much, do I? I wrote that in a state of major sleep deprivation.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I wouldn't worry dude - you're still just R-rated compared to the average Mark Prindle review on his site ;)

    Thanks for the post! Happy memories of trading Outcesticide cassettes back in school.

    Will listen to all of this later today - as soon as I've got over the HEAD A'SPLODIN awesomeness of PBTHAL POSTING KRAFTWERK 1!!!!

    cheers
    Alan, Edinburgh

    ReplyDelete
  3. wow, major score! and i didn't know that they actually performed "You Know You're Right" either! the only comparison i have to it is "Ceremony" by Joy Division--great song, post-mortem, never knew that it saw the light of day beforehand.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I apologise for turning up again in your comments section, like I don't have a life elsewhere (I don't). The Nirvana I'm a fan of is a long way from the Seattle grungekorps, but this looks like an impressive post. I watched the YouTube comparison, which was astonishing. I mean, WHY? It's like cutting off your dog's tail because you think it shows better.
    We, the great consuming public, have been sold snake-oil right from the start of CD technology, and we're still scarfing it up through "remastered" editions that are supposed to address the problems of the first-generation CD releases, which we all bought when we boxed up our vinyl. But we didn't only box up our records, we boxed up our ears. We trust in the boys in the back room, the fader sliders, and we're just wrong. Unlike vinyl, which rarely got it wrong.
    I can't play my vinyl because it's thousands of miles away, so I actually need mp3s to be able to listen to music. It's all I have. I listen to mp3s like I used to listen to pirate radio, back in the late sixties, when it was the only way to hear what you needed to hear.
    Butchering the sound AT SOURCE, like the Nirvana example, is one reason why the deeply unloveable music industry is in the shit. Just plain DUMB. And the clowns at the RIAA wonder why people download for nothing ...

    ReplyDelete
  5. Strikes me as excited to be sharing swearing. Totally appropriate considering how awesome this bootleg is. Thank you so much for posting it. Makes me really glad I skipped with With the Lights Out.

    ReplyDelete
  6. this is awesome. thanks man!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great comp, I haven't listened to Nirvana in years. Thanks for reminding me of what a great band they where..

    ReplyDelete
  8. I don't ever recall seeing that much swearing from you. Hope you got some sleep.

    I'm looking forward to hearing how much of an improvement this is over With The Lights Out, which to me, sounds pretty good, mostly.

    Thanks mucho!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Cool stuff, thanks for this. Also diggin' the Psych comps., the Jay Reatard and well I guess about everything else. I really appreciate the quality in your posts and you've opened my ears to lots of great stuff plus because of you I'm now addicted to pbthal's blogspot. What can a poor boy do? Thanks again Ian you are doing an incredible job!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I'd tell you to say hi but I'm not entirely sure she would remember me specifically. She was managing/filling in for Brad (I think) at Rhinos many nights when I went there as a kid.

    ReplyDelete
  11. AMAZING!!!!!!!! Thank you so much! What is the possibility of getting lossless copies at some point? Again, THANK YOU! THANK YOU! THANK YOU!

    ReplyDelete
  12. If you're on Demonoid,a FLAC version can be found here:

    http://www.demonoid.com/files/details/1841637/22074143/

    All I did was convert that to MP3.

    ReplyDelete
  13. "Butchering the sound AT SOURCE, like the Nirvana example, is one reason why the deeply unloveable music industry is in the shit. Just plain DUMB. And the clowns at the RIAA wonder why people download for nothing ..."

    If you round up, I would agree that about 1% of people who download for nothing do it because they're trying to teach the record industry a lesson about unnecessary compression.

    I'm not disagreeing with you about your opinion on sound quality, I just think the overwhelming majority of people who choose not to pay to download do it simply to avoid paying.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I'm tempted to upload all the official Nirvana b-sides stuff in one bunch soonish. That way you can compare the original mixes to the WITH THE LIGHTS OUT versions.

    Have a lot on my plate right now.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thanks for the post! Sharing music is a beautiful thing! I just felt compelled to address a few things you said...

    While it is very unfortunate that they compressed the hell out of With the Lights Out, it generally had way better sound quality than the bootlegs that were circulating. Compare About a Girl and Opinion to their bootleg versions and you'll find that the bootlegs sound much worse, even though they haven't suffered from over-compression. Not to mention that WTLO had a handful of gems that hadn't circulated at all before its release.

    The reason that Oh The Guilt, Curmudgeon, and Return Of The Rat sounded so bad on WTLO was because those three songs were entirely remixed and that remixing job was done incredibly poorly. So as far as that youtube video goes, the compression really has very little to do with why the 2004 version sounds so much worse.

    At the same time, it really does piss me off how much they compressed that stuff. For all the tracks on WTLO that had already had an official release, I would much rather listen to the earlier version (with the exception of Breed, which had a great rough mix on WTLO).

    As for JWB, he is certainly not in any innner circles. Nirvana still has an active trading community and all of this stuff has been available to download. JWB has simply spent lots of time downloading, as have I. (I already have all these tracks, except for some of the live stuff. R.I.P. onemoresolo.net.) JWB has also spent a great deal of time remastering countless Nirvana bootlegs. Unfortunately, JWB is REALLY BAD at remastering. I guarantee you that every song in this collection sounded much better before he touched it. As much as I love spreading good music, I really wish he'd stop because he makes everything sound awful.

    So, I'm sorry to rant on your blog like this. I'm really happy that you're sharing this stuff! But complaining about sound quality at the same time as praising JWB struck me as wrong and I had to say something. If he would just make compilations, I'd be happy, but the fact that everything he puts out sounds so terrible really pisses me off. As far as sound quality goes, he's worse than the RIAA.

    -Zak

    ReplyDelete